Ringworm
and Radiation
Barry Chamish
On August 14, at 9 PM,
"The Ringworm Children" (translated in
Hebrew as "100,000 Rays"), directed by David Belhassen
and Asher Hemias, recently won the prize for
"best documentary" at the Haifa International film festival, and in
the past year has made the rounds of Jewish and Israeli film festivals around
the world. But it had yet to come to Israeli television screens. The subject is
the mass irradiation of hundreds of thousands of young Israeli immigrants from
Middle Eastern countries -- Sephardim, as they are called today. The story goes
like this:
In 1951, the director general of the Israeli Health
Ministry, Dr. Chaim
They were to be used in a mass atomic experiment with
an entire generation of Sephardi youths to be used as
guinea pigs. Every Sephardi child was to be given
35,000 times the maximum dose of x-rays through his head. For doing so, the
American government paid the Israeli government 300 million Israeli liras a
year. The entire Health budget was 60 million liras. The money paid by the
Americans is equivalent to billions of dollars today.
To fool the parents of the victims, the children were
taken away on "school trips" and their parents were later told the
x-rays were a treatment for the scourge of scalpal
ringworm. 6,000 of the children died shortly after their doses were given,
while many of the rest developed cancers that killed thousands over time and
are still killing them now. While living, the victims suffered from disorders
such as epilepsy, amnesia, Alzheimer's disease, chronic headaches and
psychosis.
That is the subject of the documentary in cold terms.
It is another matter to see the victims on the screen.
To watch the Moroccan lady describe what getting
35,000 times the dose of allowable x-rays in her head feels like. "I
screamed make the headache go away. Make the headache go away. Make the
headache go away. But it never went away."
To watch the bearded man walk hunched down the street.
"I'm in my fifties and everyone thinks I'm in my seventies. I have to
stoop when I walk so I won't fall over. They took my youth away with those
x-rays."
To watch the old lady who administered the doses to
thousands of children: "They brought them in lines. First their heads were
shaved and smeared in burning gel. Then a ball was put between their legs and
the children were ordered not to drop it, so they wouldn't move. The children
weren't protected over the rest of their bodies. There were no lead vests for
them. I was told I was doing good by helping to remove
ringworm. If I knew what dangers the children were facing, I would never have
cooperated. Never!"
Because the whole body was exposed to the rays, the
genetic makeup of the children was often altered, affecting the next
generation. We watch the woman with the distorted face explain, "All three
of my children have the same cancers my family suffered. Are you going to tell
me that's a coincidence?"
The majority of the victims were Moroccan because they
were the most numerous of the Sephardi immigrants.
The generation that was poisoned became the country's perpetual poor and
criminal class. It didn't make sense. The Moroccans who fled to
The film made it perfectly plain that this operation
was no accident. The dangers of x-rays had been known for over forty years. We
read the official guidelines for x-ray treatment in 1952. The maximum dose to
be given a child in
David Deri makes the point
that only Sephardi children received the x-rays:
"I was in class and the men came to take us on a tour. They asked our
names. The Ashkenazi children were told to return to their seats. The dark
children were put on the bus."
The film presents a historian who first gives a potted
history of the eugenics movement. In a later sound bite, he declares that the
ringworm operation was a eugenics program aimed at weeding out the perceived
weak strains of society. The Moroccan lady is back on the screen. "It was
a Holocaust, a Sephardi Holocaust. And what I want to
know is why no one stood up to stop it."
David Deri, on film and then
as a panel member, relates the frustration he encountered when trying to find
his childhood medical records. "All I wanted to know was what they did to
me. I wanted to know who authorized it. I wanted to trace the chain of command.
But the Health Ministry told me my records were missing." Boaz Lev, the
Health Ministry's spokesman chimes in: "Almost all the records were burned
in a fire."
We are told that a
Prime Minister - David Ben Gurion;
Finance Minister - Eliezer Kaplan; Settlement
Minister - Levi Eshkol; Foreign Minister - Moshe Sharrett; Health Minister - Yosef
Burg;
Labor Minister - Golda Meir;
Police Minister - Amos Ben Gurion.
The highest ranking non-cabinet post belonged to the
Director General of the Defence Ministry, Shimon
Peres.
That a program involving the equivalent of billions of
dollars of American government funds should be unknown to the Prime Minister of
cash-strapped
Finance Minister Eliezer
Kaplan was rewarded for eternity with a hospital named after him near Rehovot. But he's not alone in this honor. Chaim
After the film ended, there was a panel discussion
which included a Moroccan singer, David Edri, head of
the Compensation Committee for Ringworm X-Ray Victims, and Boaz Lev, a
spokesman for the Ministry Of Health.
TV host Dan Margalit tried
to put a better face on what he'd witnessed. He explained meekly that "the
state was poor. It was a matter of day to day survival." Then he stopped.
He knew there was no excusing the atrocities which the Sephardi
children endured.
But it was the Moroccan singer who summed up the
experience best. "It's going to hurt, but the truth has to be told. If
not, the wounds will never heal."
There is one person alive who knows the truth: Shimon
Peres. The only way to get to the truth and start the healing is to investigate
him for his role in the mass poisoning of over 100,000 Sephardi
children and youth.
But here is why that won't happen. The film was aired
at the same time as the highest-rated TV show of the year, the finale of
First published in “Israeli-Insider”, 19.8.2004
Views expressed by the author do not
necessarily reflect those of israelinsider.